NYC Lags Behind the Private Sector in Pay Equity

By Carrie Wolfson*

The NYC Comptroller, John Liu, timed the release of his report Snapshot: Gender Equity in the New York City Municipal Workforce to coincide with Equal Pay Day. The Comptroller, along with many other pay equity experts, gathered on Tuesday, April 12th to discuss the report’s findings and the status of pay equity within NYC.

The Comptroller reported that in NYC municipal employment, women still earn only 83 cents on the dollar earned by men. In the private sector, women earn 72 cents. While the City is performing better than the private sector on this measure of pay equity, a 17% pay gap is surprising in a progressive city with strong civil service rules that should eliminate inequalities. What I found most staggering is the City’s performance with regard to its compensation paid to women with children. Controlling for many of the factors that affect pay, such as education and experience, women with children receive 24% less pay than men with children in NYC. This gap is larger than in the private sector where it is 18%.

After the Comptroller’s speech, NYC Council Members Julissa Ferreras, Letitia James and Melissa Mark-Viverito highlighted the implications of the pay gap. Council Member Ferreras made the important point that equal pay is not just about treating women fairly, it’s about saving lives. Since women are paid less, they are less able to achieve economic security independently. If a woman is dependent on an abusive partner for shelter and food, leaving can become even more difficult, especially when there are children to support. Council Member James raised the issue of the feminization of poverty, a dynamic for which pay inequities are culpable. Council Member Mark-Viverito reminded the audience that it is “pathetic” that we are still involved in the same conversation nearly half a century after the passage of the Equal Pay Act (EPA).

The pervasiveness of the wage gap demonstrates that the EPA was not sufficient to achieve pay equity. NYC’s disappointing performance compared to the private sector in its pay to women employees with children suggests that the City’s work rules are unfair. As the employer to hundreds of thousands of employees, it is time for NYC to rethink its policies.

While the findings of the Comptroller’s report are discouraging, it’s heartening that someone of Comptroller Liu’s stature seems committed to eradicating the NYC pay gap. However, statistics are only the first step. Now that we know women in the NYC municipal workforce are not receiving equal compensation, efforts need to be made to change the dynamics holding them back. Some particularly useful questions the Comptroller recommended for consideration are, “How do City policies and work rules limit the potential of women and working families?” and “What can the City do to change historic patterns of gender segregation?”

*Carrie Wolfson is a Research and Programs Intern with the National Council for Research on Women. She currently attends NYU Wagner, where she is President of the Wagner Women’s Caucus.

The opinions and commentary posted in this public forum reflect the viewpoints of guest contributors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Council for Research on Women, its member organizations, or affiliates. Contributors are responsible for the accuracy of content posted under their name.

<< Back to the Full Blog


We are glad NCRW covered the Equal Pay Day NYC event on Tuesday and the Comptroller's study. However, you neglected to mention the citywide campaign that created the event, inspired the Comptroller's research, and continues to fight for wage equity for New York women. The Equal Pay Coalition NYC, started and run by the New York Women's Agenda, has been working for five years to shed light on continuing inequities, garner support for policy and legislative reform, and educate the public and private sector about what can be done here in NY and on a federal level. The Comptroller, Council Members, and other leaders have been moved to action by our coalition of committed organizations and advocates. All are welcome to join the work!
Beverly Neufeld - President/NYWA and Director/Equal Pay Coalition NYC

Thanks Beverly for reminding us about the great work you do with the Equal Pay Coalition NYC.